Showing posts sorted by relevance for query torture yoo. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query torture yoo. Sort by date Show all posts

Wednesday, August 26, 2009

Did convicting John Yoo just get a little easier?

Possibly, judging by two tidbits from Monday's torture-doc dump.

Emptywheel notes that the docs point to "a CIA document on the 'Legal Principles' on torture that included legal justifications that had not been in any of the August 1, 2002 OLC memos authorizing torture." The IG report describes it:
OGC continued to consult with DoJ as the CTC Interrogation Program and the use of EITs expanded beyond the interrogation of Abu Zubaydah. This resulted in the production of an undated and unsigned document entitled, "Legal Principles Applicable to CIA Detention and Interrogation of Captured Al-Qa'ida Personnel." According to OGC, this analysis was fully coordinated with and drafted in substantial part by OLC. In addition to reaffirming the previous conclusions regarding the torture statute, the analysis concludes that the federal War Crimes statute, 18 U.S.C. 2441, does not apply to Al-Qa'ida "Because members of that-group are not entitled to prisoner of war status. The analysis adds that "the [Torture] Convention permits the use of [cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment] in exigent circumstances, such as a national emergency or war."
One version of this document is here; another, here (via, again, Emptywheel).

Tidbit # 1: OLC's involvement in the document, contrary to OGC's representation, seems to have been confined to the kibbitzing of one John Yoo. Jack Goldsmith wrote the IG to dissent from that portion of the report, and said quite bluntly:
OLC also believes that the status of the bullet points was made clear at a meeting on June 17, 2003 soon after the Deputy Assistant Attorney General with whom OGC had consulted on the bullet points had departed from the Department of Justice.
So Yoo was not, here, acting formally on behalf of OLC. Rather, he was acting as part of the "torture team" -- the inner circle doing its best to make torture happen.

That becomes even more clear from Tidbit # 2 (Smintheus, via 1st Emptywheel link above). The bolded portion in that quote from the Legal Principles, above? Total moonshine:
The UN Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman, or Degrading Treatment or Punishment says no such thing. The OLC/OGC lawyers evidently were insinuating that the Convention drew a very major distinction between the prohibitions against torture on the one hand, and against cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment on the other. Article 2 of the Convention states explicitly that there are no circumstances that may be used to justify torture:

No exceptional circumstances whatsoever, whether a state of war or a threat of war, internal political instability or any other public emergency, may be invoked as a justification of torture.

It is true that the Convention does not repeat the Article 2 statement when it later discusses "cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment". However that discussion (in Article 16) is extremely brief and to the point: that governments should prevent 'cruel etc. treatment' as they do torture and should give its victims the same legal recourse as victims of torture. There is no implication whatsoever in the Convention that "exigent circumstances" permit the use of cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment.

Indeed, the US wrote the following to the UN Committee against Torture ten years ago regarding its implementation of the Convention (Report of the United States to the UN Committee against Torture, October 15, 1999, UN Doc. CAT/C/28/Add.5, February 9, 2000, para. 6):

No exceptional circumstances may be invoked as a justification of torture. US law contains no provision permitting otherwise prohibited acts of torture or other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment to be employed on grounds of exigent circumstances (for example, during a "state of public emergency") or on orders from a superior officer or public authority, and the protective mechanisms of an independent judiciary are not subject to suspension.

So, when do the torture memos written by John Yoo and friends rise beyond the level of bad lawyering and into the much shadier territory of deliberate falsification for the purpose of facilitating, enabling, or encouraging torture? Because at that point I'd think even the timid Eric Holder's Justice Department would be forced to prosecute them.
From his mouth to God's ears, my friends.

... Andrew Sullivan, apparently paying a visit to his own blog, reminds us what Yoo's legal work resulted in:
Here's what the "CIA pros" did to prisoners (the non-CIA pros improvised the president's directive to torture and abuse prisoners in very similar ways): stress positions, nudity, hooding, sensory deprivation, sleep deprivation, long time standing, beatings, hypothermia, and walling. They key thing, according to the CIA, is to enhance "the potential dread a high-value detainee might have of US custody". Notice the shift from the standards of the past. In the past, the US was known for being a country whose soldiers would never mistreat prisoners; now, the US wants the world to know that US custody is something to be dreaded. * * *

John McCain will remember these techniques and variants of them from his time in the Hanoi Hilton. If this is not torture, then torture does not exist. And if this is America, and there is no accountability for these war crimes, then core American values have ceased to exist as well.
But please, let's look forward.

Saturday, February 20, 2010

OPR Bybee-Yoo report released

In a classic late-Friday document dump, some version of the OPR's evaluation of the torture memos' principal authors, Judge Jay S. Bybee and Professor John Yoo, has been released. Marcy at Emptywheel is liveblogging her reading of it, and as always is the first place to look besides the docs themselves (all of which she has linked).

Near as I can tell from the NYT story, the OPR lawyers themselves found professional misconduct, but DOJ has rejected that finding and had David Margolis write a whitewash, saying that, gosh, you just had to be there:
He said the ethics lawyers, in condemning the lawyers’ actions, had given short shrift to the national climate of urgency in which Mr. Bybee and Mr. Yoo acted after the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. “Among the difficulties in assessing these memos now over seven years after their issuance is that the context is lost,” Mr. Margolis said.
I don't remember the "context defense" at Nuremberg, but perhaps I've forgotten. What is "national climate of urgency" in the original German?

... Ambinder predicts calls to impeach Bybee and disbar Yoo (fat chance); more interesting will be how each side uses the report in the Padilla case.

... Jack Balkin is scathing:
In deciding not to refer charges to state bar committees, Margolis does not tell us that Yoo and Bybee behaved admirably or according to the high standards that we should expect from Justice Department lawyers. Indeed, he says the opposite. Yoo and Bybee exercised poor judgment and let the Justice Department down. But Margolis argues that the Office of Professional Responsibility chose too high a standard to judge the professional responsibility of Yoo and Bybee. The OPR argued that Yoo and Bybee had "a duty to exercise independent legal judgment and to render thorough, objective, and candid legal advice." This standard, Margolis explained, is much too high a requirement and not one that Yoo and Bybee were previously warned was the standard to which they would be held.

I know what you are probably saying: shouldn't every government lawyer have to live up to this standard? Of course, they should, but the point is that this is a disciplinary proceeding. It's not about what people should do, but about how badly they have to screw things up before they are subject to professional sanctions.
Interesting. If Yoo had a *duty* and violated it, that would seem to be at least negligence ....
Instead, Margolis argues that, judging by (among other things) a review of D.C. bar rules, the standard for attorney misconduct is set pretty damn low, and is only violated by lawyers who (here I put it colloquially) are the scum of the earth. Lawyers barely above the scum of the earth are therefore excused.

Margolis concludes that Yoo and Bybee exercised poor judgment and made bad legal arguments. But lawyers often make arguments that are bad or even laughably bad, and this by itself does not violate the very low standard set by rules of professional responsibility.
Are we distinguishing here between advocacy and counsel? There is a world of difference between making a bad argument in court as an advocate, because it's all your client's got, and making a bad argument in a client memo, where you are supposed to be telling your client the unvarnished truth. Any professional code that ignores this distinction is worthless.
To show misconduct, according to the standard that Margolis finds most relevant, one would have to show that Yoo or Bybee intentionally made arguments that they knew were wrong and false or did so not caring whether they were wrong or false. That standard could not be met for Jay Bybee, because Bybee was, to put it bluntly, an empty suit who relied on the advice of others and didn't analyze the memos all that closely. He just signed the papers. This makes him pathetic, but not, in Margolis's view, someone who unambiguously violated existing rules of professional responsibility.

As for John Yoo, Margolis explains (although he puts it far more diplomatically) that Yoo was an ideologue who entered government service with a warped vision of the world in which he sincerely believed. Yoo had crazy ideas even before he entered government; which strongly suggests that he probably shouldn't have been hired in the first place. Therefore it is hard to conclude that Yoo deliberately gave advice that he knew was wrong to the CIA. Yoo isn't putting people on when he says the absurd things he says in these memos and elsewhere. He actually believes that the President is a dictator and that the President doesn't have to obey statutes that make torture a crime. He actually believes that you should read the torture statute so narrowly that it lets the CIA torture people. John Yoo used every trick in the book to twist the law because he actually believes in a law that is twisted.
Even on Margolis's standard, that doesn't wash. The issue is not and cannot be whether Yoo personally believed the law *should* agree with his ideology; the issue is whether Yoo knew, or did not care to know, that his analysis was false as a description of the law.

I can just see a tax lawyer arguing that he shouldn't be sanctioned because, in his sincerely held opinion, income tax is unconstitutional, and he advised his client accordingly. That wouldn't fly; why should such an argument fly re: torture?

Tuesday, March 30, 2010

The July Days

Emptywheel provides more of her detective work on the genesis of the torture memos -- see her post here and its links to recent work on the July 13, 2002 one-page fax on which CIA apparently relied for its torture of Abu Zubaydah. Who, according to this article linked by EW, was the subject of "the massive intelligence failure that took place in the last months of the Clinton administration and during George W. Bush’s first term," such that we convinced ourselves the guy was the # 3 in al-Qaeda (first of many # 3's, to be sure).

According to EW's timeline, the first draft of the Bybee Memo (# 1?) was circulated on July 12, and then things got weirder:
What seems to have happened is the following. Yoo and Koester were all set for an NSC meeting on July 12, perhaps until they had a July 11 briefing with Chertoff. In any case, something made them reschedule that NSC meeting to arrange an Alberto Gonzales (and presumably, Addington) meeting first. After which they appear to have had an incredibly contentious meeting with Bellinger, Chertoff, Levin and others. Perhaps the fact that John Rizzo presented the latest interrogation plan (which, we suspect, was already in process anyway) made things worse. We do know, for example, that mock burial remained in the plan, even after Soufan had balked when Mitchell tried to use it two months earlier. Whether because of Rizzo’s presentation or Yoo’s draft memo, at the meeting Chertoff definitively refused an advance declination and Levin announced that FBI would have nothing more to do with CIA’s torture program.

And so Rizzo, perhaps noting that the head of DOJ’s Criminal Division and the FBI Chief of Staff were reacting rather unfavorably to CIA’s torture plan, asked Yoo for some kind of cover. In response, Yoo wrote a memo raising the bar for prosecution of inflicting severe mental suffering incredibly high.
And at the same time, we get Yoo and Koester revising the memo to include "affirmative defenses" such as the President's alleged power to ignore any statute that, in his exclusive judgment, hinders his commander-in-chief powers. Which of course was tantamount to a confession of utter legal inadequacy in the memo's construction of the Torture Act.

Tuesday, February 23, 2010

I don't read, I link posts instead

STILL haven't read the OPR documents -- hey, I've got my first-ever oral argument in the Fifth Circuit next week -- but NMC has decided to risk the inevitable food-fight in the comment thread and put up a fine post on the subject, with some good links. Check it out -- you know who you are.

... Anyone interested in the OPR memos should be checking Emptywheel's blog. This is particularly notable:
The most important ethical failure described in the OPR report pertains to how the Bybee One memo became a “Get Out of Jail Free” card.

On July 16, 2002, John Yoo went into a meeting at the White House having been told by Michael Chertoff that he couldn’t write a “Get Out of Jail Free” card. And Yoo had told his sidekick, Jennifer Koester, that they would not include sections on Commander-in-Chief power and potential defenses in torture prosecutions. Alberto Gonzales and (the OPR Report says) “possibly” David Addington and Tim Flanigan (who was then Associate White House Counsel) were at the meeting. Yoo left that meeting and--saying he had “a good idea about how we are going to do it now”--promptly started working on sections on Commander-in-Chief power and potential defenses in torture prosecutions--the sections that basically functioned as the “Get Out of Jail Free” card. When Patrick Philbin asked why he was putting those sections in the memo, Yoo explained, “They want it in there.”

All the evidence shows that someone at that meeting told Yoo not only how he could put the “Get Out of Jail Free” card back into the memo by including Commander-in-Chief ande defense sections, but that he should do so. And that shows that Yoo’s memo was not “advice,” but precisely what it appears to be: a “Get Out of Jail Free” card ordered up by the same guys who were ordering up the torture.

The trouble, however, is that OPR doesn’t know precisely what happened at that meeting.
Given the close matchup between what Yoo added, and what we know of David Addington's beliefs, I think the circumstantial evidence is highly persuasive. But that's just me.

Thursday, September 03, 2009

Whitehouse to Torture Team: Sue me ... come on, I dare ya?

Is Sheldon Whitehouse fishing for a defamation suit?
The judicial branch (which, under Marbury v. Madison, has the ultimate duty to determine "what the law is") has determined that waterboarding is torture (see U.S. v. Lee, decided in 1984 by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit). The Bush administration has admitted to waterboarding captives. The corpus delicti of that crime exists. For there to be investigation now is unexceptional.

The only exceptional thing is the parties involved: the former vice president of the United States, his counsel David Addington, Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) lawyer John Yoo and their private contractors Bruce Jessen and Jim Mitchell, psychologists who designed the torture program. But in America, high office does not put one outside the law. Indeed, it borders on unethical for a prosecutor to refuse to investigate the corpus delicti of a crime because of concern as to where the evidence may lead.
This comes close to Whitehouse's daring them to sue him. It gets better:
Looking only at the evidence that has become public so far, is there a viable theory of criminal liability arising out of this corpus delicti, the torture of America's captives?

There is substantial evidence of legal malpractice by lawyer Yoo. His opinions were even withdrawn under the Bush administration, and they are the subject of an unprecedented internal investigation by the Department of Justice. For one thing, the precise case on point was overlooked. The analysis is bad enough that it could be a sham. Investigation would reveal whether this was the result of incompetence, ideology or instruction.

There is substantial evidence of a back channel between Addington and Yoo. It is not yet clear what information or instructions passed along that back channel. It does appear to have sidelined regular chains of reporting, including the attorney general. Investigation would determine whether this was communication or conspiracy.

There is substantial public evidence of exceptional access provided to the private contractors. They were allowed to repeatedly interrupt and ultimately compromise one of the most productive interrogations in our fight against terrorism. As contractors, they were outside the military and government chains of command and reporting and thus were potentially a means of direct secret access between the White House and the torture chamber. Investigation would reveal whether this was abused.
Read the whole thing -- it's remarkable to see something so straightforward and informed from a sitting U.S. senator (the article made me check whether Whitehouse is still in office).

Wouldn't Whitehouse love for Yoo, Jessen, or Mitchell (Cheney and Addington surely are too savvy) to sue him, and then plead truth as a defense? Remember how Oscar Wilde ended up in jail.

Monday, February 22, 2010

More on the OPR report

Haven't had time to read it myself yet, but wanted to flag David Luban's critique of Margolis's memo rejecting the report's recommendations:
To be sure, one problem for OPR is that very little case law exists interpreting the rule requiring lawyers to give candid, independent advice, and none of it deals with facts remotely like this case. In its early drafts, OPR spelled out standards for when an opinion clearly violates candor and independence:

1. Exaggerating or misstating the significance of the authority that supported the desired result; 2. Ignoring adverse authority or failing to discuss it accurately and fairly; 3. Using convoluted and counterintuitive arguments to support the desired result, while ignoring more straightforward and reasonable arguments contrary to the desired result; 4. Adopting inconsistent reasoning or arguments to favor the desired result; 5. Advancing frivolous or erroneous arguments to support the desired result.

If this sounds perfectly obvious, that's because it is. Bybee and Yoo objected that these standards do not come from the case law on Rule 2.1. That is true, because the case law simply has never dealt with lawyers tailoring their advice to yield the client's desired result: the lawyer as absolver or indulgence-seller. Margolis concludes that the absence of case law on standards of candor means that the standard is ambiguous. But that certainly does not follow. Otherwise, any law that has never been interpreted by a court would automatically be ambiguous.
Moreover, remember the issue here: not whether Bybee and Yoo should be disciplined, but whether they should be referred for disciplinary proceedings. Assuming the referrals were acted upon, the Bar organizations in question would conduct, in effect, trials of their own. If it's not clear whether discipline is appropriate, then why not allow OPR to make its recommendation and let the Bar organizations sort it out?

Which just highlights the folly of giving one man, who belongs to the federal department under review, make such a decision. Bmaz at Emptywheel has more on that.

... Luban also notes that we now know the name of another author of part of the torture memos: Jennifer Koester Hardy:
Koester, who was two years out of law school and around 28 years old at the time, was clearly a junior level attorney in the process. She appears to have had no authority to approve the final versions of the memos that went out from the department, and was tasked with working with Yoo on them in part because having just joined OLC, she "had some time available," according to the report. But she did take the lead in developing the first drafts of the memos, and briefed the White House on their contents.
Quite a little project to stumble into.
The final OPR report appears not to draw any conclusions about Koester's performance. But a draft version of the report, released last week along with the final report, finds that "Koester, because of relative inexperience and subordinate position, did not commit misconduct," but that "she appears to bear initial responsibility for a number of significant errors of scholarship and judgment (p. 188)."
Of course, Bybee and Yoo had a duty to check her work, particularly anything that seemed way off, as so much did in the memos. But that was a feature, not a bug.
The report describes a process in which Koester produced numerous drafts for Yoo, then, updated them based on his and other's feedback. Koester appears to have accepted and agreed with Yoo's notoriously aggressive general approach to the torture question. Indeed, according to the report, it was Koester who drafted perhaps the most controversial section of the memos: the discussion of the "commander in chief" power, in which OLC essentially advises the government that the president, as commander in chief, can disregard any law he wants during wartime. "Koester also told us that she thinks she ended up writing the Commander-in-Chief section, with 'a lot of input' from Yoo and Philbin," writes OPR (p. 50).
Well yes, if you're going to completely make up stuff about Article II powers, give it to the 28-year-old.

After OLC, she clerked for Clarence Thomas and is now at Kirkland & Ellis. "Truly, I say unto you, you already have your reward."

... Anyone offended by the "outing" of Hardy should read this reader comment at Sullyblog.

Tuesday, May 05, 2009

Two? Who two? Yoo two?

"Former Bush Officials Work to Soften Ethics Report on Interrogations":
Former Bush administration officials are launching a behind-the-scenes lobbying campaign to urge Justice Department leaders to soften an ethics report criticizing lawyers who blessed harsh detainee interrogation tactics, according to two sources familiar with the efforts.

In recent days, attorneys for the subjects of the ethics probe have encouraged senior Bush administration appointees to write and phone Justice Department officials, said the sources, who spoke on condition of anonymity because the process is not complete.

A draft report of more than 200 pages, prepared in January before Bush's departure, recommends disciplinary action by state bar associations against two former department attorneys in the Office of Legal Counsel who might have committed misconduct in preparing and signing the so-called torture memos. State bar associations have the power to suspend a lawyer's license to practice or impose other penalties.
Hm. John Yoo and who else? Was Bybee a "department attorney"? Was Bradbury?

Before seeing this story, my money would've gone on Yoo and Bradbury. Bradbury's memos in 2005 didn't have even the dubious advantage of emergency, and were astonishingly weak. Plus, I am skeptical that even OPR wants to slag on a sitting 9th Circuit judge.

But Bybee, it seems, is not taking any chances ... and rightly so:
Two of the authors, Jay S. Bybee, now a federal appeals court judge in Nevada, and John C. Yoo, now a law professor in Southern California, faced a deadline of yesterday to respond to investigators.

Attorneys for both men did not immediately return phone calls or e-mail messages seeking comment on the reports. An e-mail to Yoo and to a court representative for Bybee also received no response. The attorneys for the men, Maureen Mahoney and Miguel Estrada, had been trying to garner support for their clients by contacting former senior Justice Department officials to prevail upon their successors in the Obama administration, sources said.

The legal analysis on interrogation prepared by a third former chief of the Office of Legal Counsel, Steven G. Bradbury, also was a subject of the ethics probe. But in an early draft, investigators did not make disciplinary recommendations about Bradbury.
About this draft report: has the reporter seen it? If not, she should be quoting "sources" about what's in the report.

Working back channels to tilt the scales on an ethics report sounds like a whole independent ethics violation itself, thinks TBA.

And if OPR does call out Bybee, it will be interesting what that does for the impeachment debate.

Anyway, we continue to eagerly await the report itself, perhaps even moreso than the Star Trek prequel (out on May 9, should you happen to be asked).

... The NYT story leads with the news that criminal prosecutions are *not* recommended. I didn't notice this omission b/c I didn't realize that was even within OPR's scope.

This was interesting:
The draft report is described as very detailed, tracing e-mail messages between Justice Department lawyers and officials at the White House and the Central Intelligence Agency. Among the questions it is expected to consider is whether the memos reflected the lawyers’ independent judgments of the limits of the federal anti-torture statute or were skewed deliberately to justify what the C.I.A. proposed.
Such messages would be the hunting grounds for evidence of conspiracy, so perhaps these e-mails don't amount to much. But I'm very curious to see them. "Skewed deliberately" sure sounds like "conspiracy to commit torture" to me.

Nothing in NYT about pressure behind the scenes. Ha! Scooped!

Thursday, May 07, 2009

Some torture with your coffee this morning?

Real life looks pretty pressing today, but here's some torture-lawyer news:

(1) Murray Waas has some inside chatter about the OPR memo on Yoo and Bybee.
Central to the OPR investigation, according to two attorneys involved, has been whether the three administration lawyers engaged in only crafting deficient legal opinions, or whether the they purposely and improperly skewed their advisory opinions to provide a legal rationale for Bush administration policies.

"Intent is everything," said a Justice Department official who was involved in overseeing the probe. "What their mindset was, whether they were writing legal opinions tailored to meet the desires of their client -- that is key to whether this was just shoddy legal work or them not meeting their professional obligations." * * *

In attempting to discern the attorneys' motives, investigators have reviewed emails traded between the three men as they drafted the legal controversial legal opinions, as well as emails between the three OLC attorneys and other Bush administration attorneys, according to sources close to the case.

Additionally, the investigators closely tracked drafts of the four legal opinions until they reached final form.

In some instances, the drafts changed progressively over time to afford those who wanted to engage in aggressive interrogation techniques additional legal cover, according to people who have read the draft OPR report.

One source indicated that at least two of the earlier drafts were "equivocal" and "nuanced" -- but noted over time they became "more advocative" of the views of then-Vice President Dick Cheney and others in the Bush administration that aggressive interrogation techniques were necessary to prevent new terror attacks.
That sounds like grist for a criminal investigation to me, but what do I know?

(2) Via Adler @ VC, a report that Yoo may be off the hook for any bar discipline, because the PA Bar has a 4-year statute of limitations on complaints. Even if they have a discovery rule, that would seem to hinder a complaint based on the memo leaked in May 2004; but what about last month's memo? (Also, I recall that someone *did* file a complaint vs. Yoo on the earlier memo, and the Bar's response was "wait and see what OPR does" -- would that toll the matter?)

(3) The leader of the Southern Baptist Convention's "ethics and public policy office" (who knew?) has gotten around to deciding that torture is just plain wrong. Unfortunately, he does this in typical Baptist fashion:
[Richard] Land, president of the SBC's Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission, said there is no circumstance in which torture should be permissible in interrogations by U.S. officials, even if the authorities believe a prisoner has information that might involve national security.

"I don't agree with the belief that we should use any means necessary to extract information," said Land. "I believe there are absolutes. There are things we must never do under any circumstances.

"For me the ultimate test is: Could I, in good conscience, do whatever I am authorizing or condoning others to do? If not, then I must oppose the action. If I could not waterboard someone--and I couldn't--then I must oppose its practice."
IOW, look inside your heart and decide what's right. Great. I expect Mr. Land will hear from a great many of his codenominationalists, who will explain that they too have searched their hearts, and would like to sign up for the next CIA waterboarding team at the Torture Olympics.

Friday, February 26, 2010

Obstruction of justice - not a crime any more?

Attention is focusing, as it should, on the apparent fact that hundreds of John Yoo's e-mails from crucial periods in the drafting of the Torture Memos have vanished. Patrick Leahy focused on this at a Senate hearing today; a subpoena is long overdue. As Scott Horton notes, "Emails at an institution like the Justice Department don’t just “disappear.” Someone deleted them. Moreover, for a deletion to be effective enough to avoid an investigation, extraordinary steps have to be taken." Indeed. John Yoo couldn't have wiped servers from his own computer; he needed help. Or else they weren't wiped and are still retrievable but DOJ has not really tried. Frankly, I suspect the latter is more plausible.

Horton also discusses how the OPR reports missed the mark:
Georgetown professor Michael Frisch, one of the District of Columbia’s leading legal ethics experts and a long-time enforcer for the D.C. Bar Council, *** eviscerated both the OPR report and the David Margolis memo. The key ethics inquiry, he argued, was under Rule 1.2(d)—whether Yoo, Bybee, and Bradbury were actually counseling a crime. In this case, the evidence that their advice was designed to facilitate torture is clear-cut, torture is a felony, and multiple players putting a scheme in place to torture is a conspiracy to torture. Yet neither the OPR report nor David Margolis even considered this question, focusing all their energy instead on two weak and rarely enforced provisions of the ethics code dealing with the duty of candor and the duty to exercise independent professional judgment.

Frisch also reviewed Margolis’s disingenuous use of D.C. case law in some detail, noting that in one key passage Margolis distorted a case that Frisch managed for the D.C. Bar. Finally, he said that the Justice Department, when presented with evidence of a serious ethics lapse by its officers, had a duty under Rule 8.3 to turn the matter over to the D.C. Bar for action. Not only did it fail to do this, its memos suggest it wasn’t even aware of the obligation. The lesson to draw from this, Frisch suggested, is that the Justice Department has failed to show it is capable of self-regulation.
I think we already knew that, but it's good to hear it from an expert.

Tuesday, April 07, 2009

First, do harm

More news on the "America tortures" front! Mark Danner's source(s) at the Red Cross have slipped him another report, this one on the participation of medical professionals in torturing prisoners.
Facilitating such practices, which the Red Cross described as torture, was a violation of medical ethics even if the medical workers’ intentions had been to prevent death or permanent injury, the report said. But it found that the medical professionals’ role was primarily to support the interrogators, not to protect the prisoners, and that the professionals had “condoned and participated in ill treatment.”

At times, according to the detainees’ accounts, medical workers “gave instructions to interrogators to continue, to adjust or to stop particular methods.”
Expect a crashing silence from the AMA and the APA.

Danner's article has a lot more in it, so take a look. In particular, he predicts that the full text of the Senate Armed Services Committee report will soon be released.

Meanwhile, Jack Balkin relays a report from Scott Horton that the Senate Republicans are conditioning the confirmation of Dawn Johnsen (OLC) and Harold Koh (State Dep't legal counsel) on a pledge *not* to investigate Bush-era torture. This is so awful, I don't even want to believe it:
Senate Republicans are now privately threatening to derail the confirmation of key Obama administration nominees for top legal positions by linking the votes to suppressing critical torture memos from the Bush era. A reliable Justice Department source advises me that Senate Republicans are planning to “go nuclear” over the nominations of Dawn Johnsen as chief of the Office of Legal Counsel in the Department of Justice and Yale Law School Dean Harold Koh as State Department legal counsel if the torture documents are made public. The source says these threats are the principal reason for the Obama administration’s abrupt pullback last week from a commitment to release some of the documents. A Republican Senate source confirms the strategy. It now appears that Republicans are seeking an Obama commitment to safeguard the Bush administration’s darkest secrets in exchange for letting these nominations go forward.
And not just the torture memos, but the OPR report on Yoo, Bybee, and Bradbury:
Republican senators have expressed strong reservations about their promised exposure, expressing alarm that a critique of the memos by Justice’s ethics office (Office of Professional Responsibility) will also be released. “There was no ‘direct’ threat,” said the source, “but the message was communicated clearly--if the OLC and OPR memoranda are released to the public, there will be war.” This is understood as a threat to filibuster the nominations of Johnsen and Koh. Not only are they among the most prominent academic critics of the torture memoranda, but are also viewed as the strongest advocates for release of the torture memos on Obama’s legal policy team.

A Republican Senate staffer further has confirmed to me that the Johnsen nomination was discussed at the last G.O.P. caucus meeting. Not a single Republican indicated an intention to vote for Dawn Johnsen, while Senator John Cornyn of Texas was described as “gunning for her,” specifically noting publication of the torture memos.
Say it with me: "The Party of Torture."

As Orin Kerr notes, "I don't know if this is true. But if it is, it makes me eager to see those memos."

... Via Sullivan, Glenn Greenwald makes a good point:
It sounds more like a responsibility-shifting excuse than anything else -- a way of blaming Republicans rather than Obama officials for the failure to disclose these memos -- but it doesn't matter in the slightest if the claims are true. There is absolutely no justification whatsoever to continue to conceal these memos, and the fact that the GOP will stomp its feet and obstruct nominees doesn't come close to constituting an excuse for ongoing concealment.

Wednesday, February 10, 2010

Binyam Mohammed "details" released

Under compulsion from their courts, the Brits have disclosed what we revealed to them about the interrogation of Binyam Mohammed:
[It was reported that a new series of interviews was conducted by the United States authorities prior to 17 May 2001 [sic] as part of a new strategy designed by an expert interviewer.

v) It was reported that at some stage during that further interview process by the United States authorities, BM had been intentionally subjected to continuous sleep deprivation. The effects of the sleep deprivation were carefully observed.

vi) It was reported that combined with the sleep deprivation, threats and inducements were made to him. His fears of being removed from United States custody and “disappearing” were played upon.

vii) It was reported that the stress brought about by these deliberate tactics was increased by him being shackled in his interviews

viii) It was clear not only from the reports of the content of the interviews but also from the report that he was being kept under self-harm observation, that the inter views were having a marked effect upon him and causing him significant mental stress and suffering.

ix) We regret to have to conclude that the reports provide to the SyS made clear to anyone reading them that BM was being subjected to the treatment that we have described and the effect upon him of that intentional treatment.

x) The treatment reported, if had been administered on behalf of the United Kingdom, would clearly have been in breach of the undertakings given by the United Kingdom in 1972. Although it is not necessary for us to categorise the treatment reported, it could readily be contended to be at the very least cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment by the United States authorities."
Sleep deprivation was of course a favorite of the Inquisition and the NKVD for obtaining confessions, true or otherwise. And death threats are clear violations of the Torture Act and/or the War Crimes Act.

The date is interesting, as Sully notes: the Bybee-Yoo torture memos were dated August 2002, and here we were using torture before then. Is that the real reason the U.S. pitched a fit about this disclosure?

... N.b. that the Brits' link says "we have alerted the court to a typographical error," which Emptywheel, correctly I think, pegs as "2001" for "2002." Post corrected. Emptywheel:
That “expert interviewer” and that “new strategy” almost certainly were associated with Mitchell and Jessen, who were at that moment pitching using their “new strategy” with Abu Zubaydah.

So this is not just proof that the US was engaging in torture before they got their CYA memo authorizing such torture. But it was proof that they were using Mohamed, in addition to Abu Zubaydah, as guinea pigs to test out that torture.

This proves the entire myth told to explain the torture memos (and Abu Zubaydah’s treatment) to be a lie.
Hopefully we'll learn more soon.

... Jim White, linked at Emptywheel's post, notes that these paragraphs had been redacted from a High Court opinion (sorry, I've never been real up on the Binyan Mohammed case). He infers that under the Convention Against Torture, the U.S. now has a duty to investigate. But (1) the treaty would probably be held not self-enforcing, and (2) an "investigation" would merely be a cover-up.

Tuesday, March 03, 2009

From Yoo, with love

I don't have anything to say about them, being uncharacteristically swamped, but Orin Kerr notes the posting at DOJ's site of various OLC memos by Yoo and Co. Prof. Kerr is unimpressed with the first one he examines; in the subsequent thread, commenters discuss how to immortalize "Yoo" as a pejorative; my favorite suggestion is for "a Yoo memo" to become slang for "a memo meant to tell the client he can do whatever he wants regardless of what the law says."

The way things are looking, that kind of slang term may be all the punishment John Yoo ever gets.

... Jack Balkin discusses the memos.

... Andrew Sullivan sums it up for us:
Just to recap: the last president believed that he had the inherent power to suspend both the First and the Fourth Amendments, he had the power to seize anyone in the US or world, disappear and torture them, and ordered his legal goons to come up with patently absurd legal rationales for all of it. And much of official Washington carried on as normal - and those of us who actually stood up and opposed this were regarded as "hysterics".
Whereas those who supported it, called themselves "conservatives."

Friday, February 13, 2009

Coming to Yoo, baby?

Brad DeLong posts what purports to be an inside tip about the OPR investigation of John Yoo:

[T]he [Justice Department's] O[ffice of] P[rofessional] R[esponsibility]... came to "very harsh conclusions" about the professional competence of a number of the [Yoo and Bradbury] memos, making "recommendations for further action" with respect to both John Yoo and Stephen Bradbury. Attorney General Mukasey and Deputy AG Filip were reported to be apoplectic about the report and to have attempted to squelch it. Their concern is... for the defense of reliance on advice of counsel that Mukasey put forward in a series of speeches, and that the OPR reports will make, I understand, something of an absurdity...

After we commenters nagged him about the provenance of this text, he amended the post to cite "Echelon Intercept #3489DE38A9." IOW, that's classified.

Interesting if true, as Mark Twain used to say of the Gospels. Meanwhile, 62% of respondents in a Gallup poll favor an investigation into "possible use of torture in terror interrogations," though only 38% of the total want that to be a criminal investigation. Of course, getting some facts out there could nudge that number up.

UPDATE: Ha - the DeLong post disappears. Emptywheel's post proves I'm not crazy, and speculates that the reason we heard about this from DeLong was that the leak came via someone connected to Berkeley. Maybe someone who didn't want his e-mail quoted either, I would now infer.

UPDATE: Orin Kerr links to Newsweek's report of an alleged OPR report unfavorable to Yoo and others. Y.t. degrades the quality of the comments thread at several points, but there are numerous valuable comments by others.

Thursday, March 05, 2009

John Yoo, a really Schmitty lawyer?

Over at TNR, Damon Linker (real name?) chides perennial dumbass Jonah Goldberg for mocking the notion that John Yoo and Carl Schmitt have anything in common:
Schmitt's primary contribution to political theory is the idea that in emergency situations, the rule of law can and must be suspended in favor of an executive act of decision about how to defend the political community against its existential enemies. This act, for Schmitt, is the supremely political act, and as such it transcends the standards of right and wrong, legal and illegal, that prevail under "normal" political conditions. It is thus incoherent to condemn such actions, since by definition they take place beyond categories that empower us to make moral and legal judgments.

Gee, sound familiar? For those who haven't been paying attention, this is precisely what our last Republican president, his vice president, and their enablers (such as David Addington and John Yoo) asserted for themselves in the years following 9/11 -- namely, that (in Andrew Sullivan's words) the president has "the inherent power to suspend both the First and the Fourth amendments," as well as "the power to seize anyone in the US or [the] world, [and] disappear and torture them" as he sees fit. Moreover, in none of these cases -- indeed, in no conceivable circumstance -- can the president be accused of breaking the law because the president's war powers automatically place him above the law. His sovereign decision -- whatever it is -- simply is the law of the land.

That is Schmittian decisionism, pure and simple. (Whether Yoo and Addington formulated their views on their own, by radicalizing the doctrine of the "unitary executive," or through reading Schmitt by flashlight in a White House broom closet is irrelevant. The ideas are nearly identical, whatever their origins.) But Schmittian assumptions were hardly limited to the executive branch of the Bush administration during the past seven years. They were so widespread among conservative intellectuals, in fact, that most of them responded to the president's decisions with enthusiasm, putting their minds to work justifying and defending his extra-constitutional actions at nearly every turn, while also impugning the motives and patriotism of those who dared challenge the president's sovereign authority.
(H/t Sullivan.)

I've read one short book by Schmitt, Political Theology, which IIRC indeed rests upon the notion that the place of God in the modern state can and must be occupied by the sovereign. Once you grant that, I suppose, everything else makes sense.

-- All this apropos of Goldberg's mocking a new book by Alan Wolfe on liberalism, in the course of which Dumbass also sneers that "Wolfe apparently thinks contemporary conservatives are disciples of Rousseau as much as, if not more, than they are followers of Burke." As we recently saw, this is less implausible than one might've thought.

... Wolfe himself chimes in. "Reading John Yoo is like overhearing Schmitt translated into English." He and Linker both have blogs at TNR? When did this happen?

Wednesday, April 08, 2009

The man who signed the torture memos

Jay Bybee, sitting pretty on the Ninth Circuit, has been one of the quieter Torture Lawyers, despite having his John Hancock on the August 2002 memo that's the most shocking we've seen to date.

Via How Appealing, we get a couple of items on Bybee.
Bybee declined to talk about his work at the Office of Legal Counsel. But when he gathered former clerks last year at a Las Vegas steak house for a five-year reunion, he was more revealing.

"He said our work has been well-researched, carefully written, and that he was very proud of the work that we've done and the opinions his chambers has issued," said Tuan Samahon , who was Bybee's first judicial clerk and is now a UNLV professor.

According to Samahon, the judge then added: "I wish I could say that of the prior job I had."
I can't cry too much for the lawyer who read John Yoo's draft memo on executive CINC power to disregard statutory law, and apparently didn't ask, "Hey, John, shouldn't there be something about Youngstown in here?"

The PDF article is also interesting for its confirmation that SERE techniques directly "informed" the torture memos:
According to information Bybee submitted to the Armed Services Committee last fall, as his office prepared the memos, Bybee saw a CIA assessment of the "psychological effects of military resistance training."

The assessment came to him in a meeting with Yoo and two other OLC attorneys in July, and Bybee told the committee that it informed the Aug. 1 memo, which is believed to have approved specific interrogation techniques, such as waterboarding.
This does not bode well for CIA's insistence that it was just following orders, methinks .... The Levine article is well worth reading in full.

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

John Yoo: "Obviously" our waterboarding was torture!

Meant to flag this excellent catch by Emptywheel a few days back, from her study of the OPR documents.
He told us during his interview: “I had actually thought that we prohibited waterboarding. I didn’t recollect that we had actually said that you could do it.” He added:

[T]he waterboarding as it’s described in that memo, is very different than the waterboarding that was described in the press. And when I read the description in the press of what waterboarding is, I was like, oh, well, obviously that would be prohibited by the statute.
As Emptywheel goes on to note, CIA and DOJ disagreed about whether DOJ was kept informed about the details of our waterboarding practice, with DOJ not recalling any such updates. (And waterboarding as described in the Bybee memos remains torture, for reasons widely discussed on the basis of those memos.)

But that's a handy reference for the next time someone tells you we didn't torture KSM or Zubaydah: "really? because John Yoo thinks we did."

Thursday, April 16, 2009

Torture Lawyers' vacation plans back on?

Contrary to earlier reports, Spain seems unlikely to indict Yoo, Bybee, et al.:
Spain's attorney general has rejected opening an investigation into whether six Bush administration officials sanctioned torture against terror suspects at Guantanamo Bay, saying Thursday a U.S. courtroom would be the proper forum.

Candido Conde-Pumpido's remarks severely dampen the chance of a case moving forward against the Americans, including former U.S. Attorney General Alberto Gonzales. Conde-Pumpido said such a trial would have turned Spain's National Court "into a plaything" to be used for political ends.

"If there is a reason to file a complaint against these people, it should be done before local courts with jurisdiction, in other words in the United States," he said in a breakfast meeting with journalists.
Not sure how this fits with the fact that Spanish nationals are said to've been victims at Gitmo, but then, it seems that the wonderfully-named Candido Conde-Pumpido has motives beyond the merely legal:
[The proposed indictment] alleged that the men — who have become known as "The Bush Six" — cleared the path for torture by claiming in advice and legal opinions that the president could ignore the Geneva Conventions, and by adopting an overly narrow definition of which interrogation techniques constituted torture.

But Conde-Pumpido rejected that argument, saying the case had no merit because the men did not themselves commit the alleged abuses.

"If one is dealing with a crime of mistreatment of prisoners of war, the complaint should go against those who physically carried it out," Conde-Pumpido said.

Gonzalo Boye, one of the human rights lawyers who brought the case in Spain, said the decision by Conde-Pumpido was politically motivated and set a terrible course for Spanish justice.

"The attorney general speaks of the court being turned into a plaything. Well, I don't think the attorney general's office should be turned into a plaything for politicians," Boye told AP. "It is a terrible precedent if those intellectually responsible for crimes can no longer be held accountable."
Conde-Pumpido's votes at Nuremberg, had he been a judge there, can presumably be inferred. Goering didn't kill any Jews, after all.

Presumably this is the result of some phone calls from Washington to Madrid. I'll be curious to see whether the release of further memos has any effect on Spain, or provokes any other prosecutors to get frisky.

Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Justice delayed, justice denied

Delayed:
On the bright and sunny Sunday afternoon of January 30, 1972, British paratroopers, using high-velocity self-loading rifles, fired at a number of civilians in the Bogside area of Londonderry, killing 13 and wounding another 13. There are few parallels in English history to such an event involving British soldiers and British civilians. Parliament immediately adopted a resolution calling for an inquiry, and the Lord Chief Justice of England, the Right Honorable Lord Widgery, was appointed to preside. The Tribunal, which sat in the County Hall at Coleraine, a small town 30 miles from Londonderry, commenced hearing testimony on February 21 and continued until March 14. During this time 17 sessions were held, at which 114 witnesses gave evidence subject to cross examination. Thereafter three further sessions took place in the Royal Courts of Justice in London at which closing arguments of counsel were heard. On April 10, 1972, the Lord Chief Justice submitted his Report of the Tribunal. This Report was made public on April 18, 1972. It was a complete and utterly outlandish whitewash.

Over the following twenty-five years, journalists, lawyers, and human-rights investigators demolished Lord Widgery’s report--and, for posterity’s sake, his reputation as a fair-minded judge. By 1998, the British government was forced to acknowledge that the Widgery report was a mockery of critical investigation. Lord Saville was appointed to review the incident ab initio. Today, the Saville inquiry has released its long awaited conclusions. As anticipated, it has almost completely reversed the Widgery report. All the victims were exonerated; none of the killings was found to have been justified. The way has now been opened for prosecutions of those who used unwarranted lethal force that day in 1972. The Saville report took an extraordinary amount of time to wind to its conclusions, but this time the effort was solid.
Denied:
Apparently, this country has deemed it okay to take an innocent Canadian citizen transiting through US airports and instead send them to a third country to be tortured. That seems to be the lesson from SCOTUS’ decision to deny Maher Arar cert in his suit against the US. From a CCR press release on the decision:

Today, the United States Supreme Court decided not to hear the Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR) case on behalf of Canadian citizen Maher Arar against U.S. officials for their role in sending him to Syria to be tortured and detained for a year.

The decision of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, which the Supreme Court declined to review, was decided on the legal ground that Congress, not the courts, must authorize a remedy. As a result, the substance of Mr. Arar’s case, first filed in January 2004, has never been heard and now never will be.

Mr. Arar said, “Today’s decision eliminates my last bit of hope in the judicial system of the United States. When it comes to ‘national security’ matters the judicial system has willingly abandoned its sacred role of ensuring that no one is above the law. My case and other cases brought by human beings who were tortured have been thrown out by U.S. courts based on dubious government claims. Unless the American people stand up for justice they will soon see their hard-won civil liberties taken away from them as well.”

Last month, the Obama administration chose to weigh in on Mr. Arar’s case for the first time. The Obama administration could have settled the case, recognizing the wrongs done to Mr. Arar as Canada has done. (Canada conducted a full investigation, admitting wrongdoing, exonerated Mr. Arar, apologized, and paid him $10 million in damages for their part in his injuries.) Yet the Obama administration chose to come to the defense of Bush administration officials, arguing that even if they conspired to send Maher Arar to torture, they should not be held accountable by the judiciary.
Both on Monday, June 14.

Will it take 38 years for a commission to decide that Arar was entitled to bring his suit after all, and to show what a "whitewash" the Second Circuit's en banc decision was? Not to mention all the other victims of America's turn to torture? Will Maher Arar, John Yoo, and other principal victims and perpetrators even be alive then?

As Judge Calabresi predicted in his dissent:
But this does not alter my conviction that in calmer times, wise people will ask themselves: how could such able and worthy judges have done that?
He politely omits the follow-up question: were such judges really able and worthy after all? That's the question about Lord Widgery; it will be the question about our judges and justices as well.

... David Cole, one of Arar's lawyers, has a blog post at NYRB that notes a catch-22:
In President Obama’s May 2009 speech on national security and American values, he opposed a commission to investigate torture by arguing that there were proceedings in the courts that could provide accountability. Yet in the Arar case--as in every other civil case that has sought accountability for torture--the Obama administration argued that the courts were not an appropriate forum.
Despicable.

Wednesday, April 01, 2009

Who's running this place?

This story came out last week, but the NYT has now deigned to notice:
The Obama administration is intensely debating whether and when to release documents from the Bush administration related to harsh interrogation methods used on prisoners belonging to Al Qaeda, according to administration and Congressional officials.

Some officials, including Gregory B. Craig, the White House counsel, and Attorney General Eric H. Holder Jr., have argued for disclosing the material as quickly as possible to distance the new administration from the most controversial policies of the Bush years. Mr. Holder and other top officials have condemned the most extreme of the past interrogation techniques, waterboarding, as illegal torture, and they see no reason to hide from public view what they consider the mistakes of their predecessors.

But some former and current Central Intelligence Agency officials say a rush to release classified material could expose intelligence methods and needlessly offend dedicated counterterrorism officers. Some administration and Congressional officials said John O. Brennan, a C.I.A. veteran who now serves as President Obama’s top counterterrorism adviser, has urged caution in disclosing interrogation documents.
Another reason to thank God we didn't put Brennan atop CIA.

"Needlessly offend CIA officers" -- fuck 'em. If they're the kind of people to get their panties in a wad, they shouldn't be at CIA in the first place.

"Expose intelligence methods" -- really? Exposing *torture techniques*? Those are "intelligence methods" now?

There's also an update on the OPR review of Yoo et al:
On Tuesday, two Democratic senators, Richard J. Durbin of Illinois and Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island, wrote to the Justice Department to complain about delays in the release of a report by the its ethics office on the role of department lawyers in providing legal advice on waterboarding and other interrogation methods under President Bush.

A draft of the report completed in December by the department’s Office of Professional Responsibility is described by officials who have been briefed on its contents as highly critical of three authors of legal memorandums on interrogation: Jay S. Bybee, John C. Yoo and Mr. Bradbury.

Answering a query from the two senators last week, M. Faith Burton, the acting head of legislative affairs at the Justice Department, suggested that the report was far from ready for public release. She said copies had been given to the former department lawyers whose work it criticizes and the department was awaiting their comments before beginning additional reviews.

“Due to the complexity and classification level of the draft report, the review process described above likely will require substantial time and effort,” Ms. Burton wrote.
I must presume there's a time limit on the replies, so that the lawyers can't delay the report indefinitely. But who knows. Of course, if the memos were all made public, perhaps the "classification level" would drop a few notches?

Friday, April 24, 2009

Bad apples. Bad branches. Bad tree. Bad fucking orchard.

Scott Horton draws attention to
an amazing document that Attorney General Eric Holder released yesterday, which has still gained little attention. The Holder note presents a summary of CIA interaction with the White House in connection with the approval of the torture techniques that John Yoo calls the “Bush Program.” Holder’s memo refers to the participants by their job titles only, but John Sifton runs it through a decoder and gives us the actual names.
Maybe I've missed this before, but this seems huge to me. Observe:
“[The] CIA’s Office of General Counsel [this would include current Acting CIA General Counsel John Rizzo] met with the Attorney General [John Ashcroft], the National Security Adviser [Condoleezza Rice], the Deputy National Security Adviser [Stephen Hadley], the Legal Adviser to the National Security Council [John Bellinger], and the Counsel to the President [Alberto Gonzales] in mid-May 2002 to discuss the possible use of alternative interrogation methods [on Abu Zubaydah] that differed from the traditional methods used by the U.S. military and intelligence community. At this meeting, the CIA proposed particular alternative interrogation methods, including waterboarding.”

The report continues to implicate more Bush officials: “On July 13, 2002, according to CIA records, attorneys from the CIA’s Office of General Counsel [including Rizzo] met with the Legal Adviser to the National Security Council [Bellinger], a Deputy Assistant Attorney General from OLC [likely John Yoo], the head of the Criminal Division of the Department of Justice [Michael Chertoff], the chief of staff to the Director of the Federal Bureau of Investigation [Kenneth Wainstein], [Who he? -TBA] and the Counsel to the President [Alberto Gonzales] to provide an overview of the proposed interrogation plan for Abu Zubaydah.”
Wowzers. We had assumed, ever since the first August 2002 torture memo came out, that such shoddy "advice" had to be written for the purpose of authorizing what someone had already decided to do. But this is the first thing that, in essence, confirms that was the case.

(Yes, in theory, CIA could've had this wish list but still been ready to drop it if OLC said no, and OLC could've been advising in good faith that all this was really okay ... if you believe that, I have some excellent mortgage-backed securities I'd like to sell you (and yes, I believe I have used that joke before, but no one reads my cruddy blog, so HAH)).

So, the $64,000 question: Where's Cheney? None of these people were Cheney's or Addington's creatures. Is Cheney less culpable than we'd imagined? Or -- and this is certainly what I'd expect CIA to say, but their motives are suspect -- did CIA "originate" this request at the behest of the Office of the Vice-President?

Scooter Libby had Addington's job back then, right? We suspected Cheney couldn't afford to let Libby go to prison -- the day the marshals came to pick him up, Libby might have started remembering a lot of things.